Let me say right at the outset–I don’t know how good the Buffalo Bills are going to be this season. I honestly don’t know how much better they are than a year ago, when they won seven games.
But I know this–I do not base my evaluation on the Bills on their preseason performances so far. Not the mildly impressive showing against the Bears two weeks ago. Not the abysmal showing at Green Bay last Saturday.
The chicken littles are convinced the sky is falling on One Bills Drive, because the Bills laid an egg at Lambeau Field. They are ready to give up on Edwards, fire the head coach now, and scrap the no-huddle offense. Or maybe Edwards should call his own plays in the no-huddle. Or maybe the Bills should switch to a 3-4 defense. Or maybe…maybe…
Maybe everyone should relax. These games do not count. The fact that the starting offense has yet to find the end zone in its’ first four quarters of play (over three preseason games) is something to be concerned with. But it does not mean all is lost.
I go back to what former Bills LB London Fletcher told me once about preseason games. “They don’t count, but they matter.” I think it’s the best assesment of NFL preseason football I’ve ever heard.
What matters is that Trent Edwards is still working through his issues, still finding the fine line between being careful with the football — avoiding turnovers, and fitting the ball into tight spots downfield. It’s what separates great NFL quarterbacks from mediocre ones. I’m not sure Edwards is great, but I think he’s better than mediocre. And I’m OK with giving him a couple of more preseason games to find his comfort level.
What matters is that the Bills have not established a strong running game yet in three preseason games. Neither the starters nor the backups have shown they can run the ball consistently.
What matters is that the newly constituted offensive line has much more work to do to become a cohesive, effective unit. The rookie guards are undergoing a baptism by fire this preseason. It can only make them better when the games count.
What ALSO matters, is that the Bills are working through the real business of preseason–finding the right 53-players to put on the roster.
I submit that TE Shawn Nelson, TE Jonathan Stupar, LB Nick Harris, RB Xavier Omon, CB Ellis Lankster and DE Chris Ellis have opened some eyes on the coaching staff with their play in preseason games. I want to see more of them. I also want to see DE Aaron Maybin and FS Jairus Byrd in the final two preseason games, to see what kind of contributions they might be able to make.
Watching an NFL roster take shape in preseason, is a lot like the old saw about watching sausage being made—you don’t want to do it–you’ll lose your taste for sausage. Unfortunately, preseason football is all we have for a couple of more weeks. There are times when it’s not for the faint of heart.
The Bills have a lot more work to do to be ready for September 14th. They have three weeks left to do it. It’s foolish to make sweeping decisions about quarterbacks, coaches, or other key players based on preseason performances so far.